When searching for a new pair of headphones, a Bluetooth speaker, or a home stereo system there are several factors one needs to consider to ultimately make the best purchase decision. Depending on what your intended use is, you may focus on waterproofing, Bluetooth range, or price point. However, in most scenarios sound quality is going to be the key factor in your purchase. This is where understanding sound signatures can become extremely useful.
When you are able to understand how sound signatures work, it will allow you to better understand product reviews where the more technical details of the speaker are covered. It will allow you to select a product that best matches what it is that you’re looking for.
The first and most important concept to understand is how we perceive sound; this is a process known as transduction. To put it simply, when a sound is generated, air pressure fluctuations occur, these vibrations are interpreted through a series of components within our ear and converted into electrical signals that our brain can understand as sound.
The air pressure fluctuations are identified as frequencies, of which we can hear the range of around 20Hz to 20kHz. When looking at an audio device’s performance based on technical specifications, the frequency response is incredibly important, as it gives us a basic idea of what frequency bands may or may not be exaggerated or lacking.
For example, a certain speaker might have an emphasis on the bass response and poor high-end clarity, while another may have superb high-end definition but weak bass. These are what we know as sound signatures, and many consumer-grade audio devices adopt one of the below commonly-utilized signatures.
Types of Sound Signatures
Flat Frequency Response
|Examples||Studio reference monitors, open-back headphones, professional in-ear monitors|
|Best for||Critical listening, recording, mixing & mastering|
|Works Well With||While any music style can be enjoyed on a flat response system, fans of bass-heavy music might find a flat signature to be unexciting.|
Sound engineers and audiophiles favor flat frequency responses as they provide the listener with the most accurate representation of the musical content, the way it left the recording studio.
For casual listeners, flat sound signatures may sound boring, as most consumer-grade devices are designed to enhance certain frequency bands. It is worth noting that no device is entirely flat, and our ears also do not operate in a linear fashion when it comes to frequency perception. Flat response devices are often pricier as they are used for more professional applications.
Balanced Sound Signature
|Examples||Studio monitors, audiophile headphones or speakers, PA systems|
|Best for||Critical listening, audio engineering, radio, gaming, TV|
|Works Well With||All music genres, spoken word|
Balanced sound signatures can be described as a slightly enhanced flat response. Rather than an entirely flat signature, balanced devices feature slight enhancements and cuts in specific frequency bands to deliver a pleasurable listening experience that can be considered relatively accurate to the original source.
U-Curve Sound Signature
|Examples||Hi-Fi or home stereo systems, most earphones and headphones|
|Best for||Casual listening, radio, gaming|
|Works Well With||All music styles, spoken word|
The V-Curve is one of the most popular sound signatures and is based on an emphasis on low-end and high-end, with a slightly scooped midrange. This sound signature enhances the ‘exciting’ content in a piece of music by boosting low-frequency content, providing additional ‘pump’ and warmness to a track, as well as improving the treble region which improves the intelligibility of vocals, and provides an overall warmer tonal signature.
V-Curve Sound Signature
|Examples||Car audio, Bluetooth speakers, many earphones/headphones|
|Best for||Casual listening, radio, gaming|
|Works Well With||Electronic music, pop, hip-hop, metal|
The V-Curve is arguably the most commonly used sound signature, along with the U-Curve. The V-Curve is essentially a more exaggerated version of the U-Curve sound signature. For some, this provides a great enhancement to the overall listening experience, although the sound you’re hearing is considerably different from the original source signal.
|Examples||Dance-music specialty speakers & headphones, car audio, Bluetooth speakers|
|Best for||Casual listening|
|Works Well With||Electronic music, hip-hop|
A boosted bass sound signature is another of the more commonly-used sound signatures and is often available as an additional feature on many Bluetooth speakers that can be activated or disabled as you please. While a bass boost signature brings the low-end to life and will without a doubt get the dancefloor open, this often results in a serious deterioration of upper midrange and treble clarity.
|Examples||Specialty speakers and earphones, smaller Bluetooth speakers or cheaper devices|
|Best for||Casual listening or hard of hearing listening|
|Works Well With||Orchestral, spoken word|
A treble boost sound signature ultimately brightens the overall sonic qualities of whatever source signal is being fed through the device. This is not a common signature but can sometimes be found as an additional feature on portable playback systems.
A treble boost signature can be helpful for those hard of hearing, as our perception of the higher frequencies is often the first portion of our hearing range to suffer through age or exposure-related accidents.
Cheaper audio gear can also sometimes be perceived as having a treble boost signature, where in actual fact, the speaker just lacks the power to represent the low end accurately, the same applies to small speakers that struggle with bass response.
The Harman Curve
Harman International, the parent company behind many well-known brands including JBL, Lexicon, DBX, and Crown, developed their own sound signature, known as the Harman Curve, in 2010.
The purpose of the Harman Curve signature is ultimately to combine the best features of everyone’s favorite sound signatures, creating a signature that replicates a room full of speakers as closely as possible. From an audio engineer’s perspective, it is clearly based on a U-Curve with some additional tweaks along the frequency spectrum, almost a well-balanced point between a Balanced and U-curve signature.
The Harman Curve is implemented in many of their audio products, including household brand, JBL. This is what gives JBL speakers that characteristically powerful tonal structure.
Creating Your Own Sound Signature
Many Hi-Fi/Stereo systems, car heads, and Bluetooth speakers allow you to customize the sound signature of the device using either a selection of EQ presets or a fully-customizable EQ to craft your own sound to best suit your listening preferences.
The degree to which you can modify your sound signature with EQ will depend on the product. Some products only allow modification on fairly large bands of frequency, while others will offer a more detailed adjustment, where you can adjust each 100Hz or more.
When you’re dealing with Bluetooth speakers, you’re usually quite limited in the EQ control, however, if you’re using a computer you can easily download impressive EQ software that will allow you to dial in your headphone or speakers sound signatures to an impressive degree.
Just beware that extreme boosting of certain frequency regions can cause a speaker to distort if it can’t handle the frequency content, or even blow if overwhelmed. If you’re looking to create your own EQ patch, here are some simple guidelines to follow.
Aside from the sound signature of an audio system, one must also pay attention to several other elements that have an influence on the sonic performance of an audio device:
The Price of a device often helps us to learn how an audio device might sound. Cheaper units are built from cheaper components, from the driver materials, connectors, and Bluetooth codec to the speaker enclosure construction itself.
Generally, cheaper systems struggle with the low-end and often possess an overall weak-sounding performance.
Brand or Intended Use of a device
The Brand or Intended Use of a device will absolutely have an impact on how satisfied you may be with your new audio device.
A flat response system certainly won’t excite a bass-head who listens exclusively to electronic music styles that call for emphasized low-end, in the same way, that a jazz listener might not enjoy a heavily bass-boosted speaker system. If you’re buying a device for critical listening, you’ll have better luck looking at pro audio brands over top-of-the-range consumer brands.
Speaker Placement is another very important element to consider. For casual listening, you can get away with pretty much anything really, however, if you want to get the most out of your new sound system, it’s worth taking a look at an installation guide to determine speaker height, angles, and listening distance before hooking it up.
Additionally, the surroundings, directionality, and materials the speaker is placed on will have an effect on sound qualities, so take this into consideration too.
The Driver Size within the speaker greatly affects the sound signature. Larger drivers are designed for low-frequency replication, while higher frequencies are handled by smaller drivers.
A speaker that consists of a series of drivers (a woofer, midrange, and tweeter combo, for example) will sound far ‘better’ than a single-driver unit that’s attempting to produce the entire frequency spectrum. This factor is heavily influenced by your intended listening material.
Speaker Construction is yet another important factor to consider, as different materials can be used all with their own tonal properties that will affect the speaker’s sonic qualities.
The construction of a speaker is another discussion of its own, however, it is important to note the differences between a speaker made from different plastics or woods and how this affects the sound.
Leave a reply